It’s a universally acknowledged truth that dinnerware sets tend to be quite pricey. They fall into that category of items that seem to carry a higher price tag than they should, alongside bath towels, bed sheets, and outdoor furniture.
Yet, the right dinnerware has the power to transform any table setting. With a vast array of styles available, ranging from classic, all-white plates to those reminiscent of a chic bistro to ceramics designed to emulate handmade pieces, there’s something to suit every taste. Regardless of the set chosen—and its price tag—dinnerware must meet certain criteria: functionality, durability, and, ideally, aesthetic appeal.
This leads me to a revelation that surprised me, given my penchant for clearly identifying “winners” and “losers” as an equipment reviewer. Despite testing 17 sets priced between $42 and $589 ($2.25 to $33.50 per piece on average), the overwhelming majority of the dinnerware performed adequately.
While there were a couple of sets that our testing panel deemed mediocre and some objective factors such as susceptibility to scratching were worth noting, it could be argued that most sets could find their place with a specific type of consumer, within a certain price range, or to fit a particular aesthetic.
Tests
Initial Unboxing Assessment: Upon opening the dinnerware sets, we meticulously inspected each piece for any glaze imperfections, scratches, or signs of damage. Additionally, we recorded the weight of each piece.
Aesthetics and Handling Evaluation: Four different users assessed each set, providing feedback on its visual appeal, design, tactile feel, and noteworthy observations.
Mug Comfort Test: We tested the comfort of holding and drinking from the mugs in each set by sipping hot coffee.
Durability Examination: Using both dinner and steak knives, we deliberately scratched the surface of the salad and dinner plates in each set, checking for any resulting damage.
Staining Resistance Test: We mixed oil and turmeric on each dinner plate and let it sit for three hours before washing it to test stain resistance. We then examined for any residual stains, oil marks, or odors.
Microwave Compatibility Assessment: We chilled the bowls from each set, filled them with water at room temperature, and microwaved them for a specific duration to evaluate temperature resistance and microwave safety.
Dishwasher Endurance Test: One place setting from each set underwent a rigorous dishwasher cycle, simulating real-life use with a less-than-gentle loading approach. We inspected for any signs of damage post-wash.
Steak Test (for Winners Only): The dinner plates from our preferred sets underwent a steak slicing test using a steak knife to observe any effects on the plates’ surface or leakage of juices.
Extended Daily Use Assessment (for Winners Only): Selected winners were put into daily rotation, and we plan to update our review with further observations after a few months of use.
Key Takeaways:
When choosing a set of plates
it’s essential to consider your specific preferences and needs. The variety continued while each set we evaluated included standard dinner and salad plates. Some sets featured additional items like pasta or soup bowls, dessert plates, or mugs. We found sets with two bowls (one small, one large) particularly appealing, as they provided versatility for different dining occasions (for instance, we often enjoy meals in oversized bowls at home).
However, the ideal composition of a dinnerware set is highly subjective. You may prioritize having a set of mugs, or you already own the preferred soup bowls. Ultimately, the dinnerware set should align with your preferences and dining habits.
We tested flatware sets to identify the top choices for daily use.
It’s essential to consider the aesthetic you desire. Whether you prefer a colorful, modern, all-white versatile style, a bistro ambiance, or a more sophisticated feel, the choice is yours.
Additionally, it’s worthwhile to contemplate your purchasing approach for dinnerware.
We preferred sets that offered the option of being bought as complete sets or as individual place settings and pieces. This flexibility allows you to expand your set or replace broken pieces gradually.
Determining Your Budget:
The question of how much to spend on dinnerware is highly personal and dependent on your financial situation. Our selection of winners encompasses a range of price points, ensuring options for every budget. While our testing panel quickly identified the pricier sets, our budget-friendly choice from AmazonBasics proved reliable. Although it may lack exceptional features, its simple all-white design is functional and ideal for those seeking affordability, such as furnishing on a tight budget, outfitting a college student, or equipping a camper or RV. With an average cost of $2.25 per piece, it offers decent value without breaking the bank.
Comparison of Plate and Bowl Designs:
Wide Rims with Angled Sides:
Several sets featured plates and bowls with wide rims, often accompanied by angled sides. While these designs reduced the flat plate space, the wide rims were convenient grips, handy when handling hot dishes from microwaves or ovens. Additionally, higher walls on these pieces helped to keep food neatly centered on the plate.
Plates with Short, Straight Walls:
Plates sporting short, straight walls offered a modern aesthetic that appealed to our testers. These plates boasted broad, flat surfaces, providing ample room for food placement. However, the expansive plate space sometimes made steak slide around as it was cut and consumed.
Plates with Gentle Slopes:
Alternatively, some plates featured walls with gentler slopes. This design struck a balance between wide-rimmed plates with steep sides and those with straight walls. Despite still offering ample flat surface area for food, the slight slopes aided in containing food items without sacrificing usability.
Some of the mug handles had an unpleasant odor.
We favored smaller mugs as they facilitated faster cooling of coffee, ensuring you could enjoy a cup before it became cold and unpleasant. We also preferred handles that allowed at least two fingers to wrap around them comfortably. However, some mugs featured small, looped handles that were more difficult to grip. Despite this, drinking from the mugs was generally satisfactory, as most had thin and inconspicuous rims.
Plate Scratch Resistance and Durability Assessment:
Overall, porcelain demonstrated superior scratch resistance during our testing, showing remarkable resilience against any marking. On the other hand, ceramic stoneware proved to be more susceptible to scratching. Despite this, most scratches observed were minimal, even under rigorous testing conditions with a steak knife.
Furthermore, it’s noteworthy that nearly all the dinnerware sets emerged unscathed from both our staining and dishwasher tests, demonstrating their resilience and durability in real-life usage scenarios.
Key Considerations: Choosing the Right Dinnerware Set
Our preference leaned towards dinnerware sets offered as complete collections with the option to purchase additional place settings or individual pieces separately. This flexibility allows for effortless expansion of your collection or replacement of damaged items. We prioritized sets that boasted scratch and stain-resistant properties, with particular attention to mugs that offered comfortable drinking experiences, if included. Regarding pricing, many excellent dinnerware options are available across various budgets.
1- Fiesta 4-Piece Place Setting, Lapis
The Fiesta 4-Piece Place Setting in Lapis is a quintessential addition to any table setting. Crafted with precision in the USA, it boasts a vitrified ceramic body, ensuring durability and longevity. The lead-free glaze not only enhances its aesthetic appeal but also assures safety. What’s more, this set is designed to withstand the rigours of daily use, being dishwasher, microwave, and oven safe. With a generous 5-year chip resistance warranty, you can indulge in worry-free dining experiences. Elevate your dining ambiance with the timeless elegance and practicality of the Fiesta 4-Piece Place Setting.
Specifications:
| Specification | Details |
|---|---|
| Material | Vitrified Ceramic |
| Color | Lapis |
| Origin | USA |
| Glaze | Lead-Free |
| Care | Dishwasher, Microwave, Oven safe |
| Warranty | 5-year chip resistance |
Why Should You Buy This?
Investing in the Fiesta 4-Piece Place Setting in Lapis offers a multitude of benefits:
- Its origin in the USA ensures superior craftsmanship and quality control.
- The vitrified ceramic body guarantees longevity, making it a worthwhile investment for your tableware collection.
- Its lead-free glazing prioritizes your family’s protection while improving its aesthetic appeal. The convenience of being dishwasher, microwave, and oven-safe adds to its appeal, making it suitable for modern lifestyles.
- The 5-year chip resistance warranty speaks volumes about the manufacturer’s confidence in the product’s durability.
Overall, purchasing this place setting ensures elegance, practicality, and peace of mind.
Pros:
- Chip-resistant triple-layer glass ensures durability.
- The lightweight design allows for easy handling and stacking.
Cons:
- Limited color options are available.
2- Corelle Vitrelle 18-Piece Service for 6 Dinnerware Set
If you’re searching for dinnerware that combines durability with elegance, the Corelle Vitrelle 18-Piece Service for 6 Dinnerware Set is an excellent choice. Crafted from triple-layer glass, this set is chip-resistant and lightweight, making it a practical yet stylish addition to any dining table.
Specifications:
| Item | Description |
|---|---|
| Material | Triple-layer-strong glass |
| Set Includes | (6) 10-1/4-inch dinner plates |
| (6) 6-3/4-inch appetizer plates | |
| (6) 18-oz soup/cereal bowls | |
| Features | Chip resistant |
| Lightweight | |
| Dishwasher safe | |
| Microwave safe | |
| Warranty | 3-year limited warranty |
Why Should You Buy This?
The 18-piece Corelle Vitrelle Service for 6 Dinnerware Set is the ideal balance of fashion and practicality. Its chip-resistant triple-layer glass construction ensures long-lasting durability, while its lightweight design makes it easy to handle and stack.
The set is perfect for regular use and special events because of its timeless design and soft-gray borders, which give refinement to any dining experience. Additionally, being dishwasher and microwave-safe, this dinnerware set offers convenience in cleaning and reheating. You may shop confidently, knowing your investment is safeguarded thanks to a 3-year limited warranty.
Pros:
- Classic style with soft-gray borders adds elegance to any table setting.
- Comes with a 3-year limited warranty for added peace of mind.
Cons:
- Some users may prefer a larger variety of plate sizes.
3- Gibson Home Rockaway Round Stoneware Dinnerware Set, Service for 4 (12pcs), White
Are you looking to add a touch of modern elegance to your dining table? The Gibson Home Rockaway Round Stoneware Dinnerware Set is a must-have. This 12-piece set, designed to serve 4, combines functionality with style to elevate your dining experience.
Specifications:
| Item | Description |
|---|---|
| Material | Stoneware |
| Set Includes | (4) 10.5” Dinner Plates |
| (4) 8” Dessert Plates | |
| (4) 6” (26.5 oz) Bowls | |
| Care Instructions | Microwave and dishwasher safe |
| Design | Matte glaze with smooth, flat finish |
| Modern simplicity with off-white rim | |
| Coupe-shaped edges for stackable design |
Why Should You Buy This?
For those looking for a dinnerware set that combines design and durability, Gibson Home’s Rockaway Round Stoneware Dinnerware Set is ideal. This set is functional and visually appealing, crafted from high-quality stoneware and featuring a matte glaze finish. The coupe-shaped sides provide convenience by enabling stackable and space-saving storage.
At the same time, the contemporary style with an off-white ring lends a touch of elegance to any kitchen or dining area. Additionally, being microwave and dishwasher safe, this dinnerware set offers convenience in both usage and maintenance. Overall, with its sleek design and durable construction, the Gibson Home Rockaway set is an excellent investment for any home.
Pros:
- Microwave and dishwasher safe for convenient use and cleaning.
- Stoneware material offers durability and a sleek aesthetic.
Cons:
- Limited color options were available.
4- Gibson Soho Lounge Round Reactive Glaze Stoneware Dinnerware Set, Service for 4 (16pc), Blue, Soho Round.
Elevate your dining experience with the Gibson Soho Lounge Round Reactive Glaze Stoneware Dinnerware Set. This set, designed to serve 4, exudes contemporary elegance with its artisanal reactive glaze and natural organic hues.
Specifications:
| Item | Description |
|---|---|
| Material | Stoneware |
| Set Includes | (4) 12.75” Dinner Plates |
| (4) 9” Dessert Plates | |
| (4) 6.25” (22.7 OZ) Bowls | |
| (4) 12 OZ Mugs | |
| Care Instructions | Dishwasher and microwave safe |
| Features | Double reactive glaze |
| Contemporary design | |
| Durable stoneware construction |
Why Should You Buy This?
For those looking for durable and fashionable tableware, the Gibson Soho Lounge Round Reactive Glaze Stoneware tableware Set is a must. The unique artisanal reactive glaze creates a stunning visual appeal with vibrant colors and hues that are sure to impress guests. Additionally, each piece is one-of-a-kind, adding a touch of individuality to your dining experience.
Constructed from durable stoneware, this set is built to last, resisting scratches and breaks. Its contemporary design adds a modern elegance to any table setting, making it perfect for everyday use or special occasions. And with its dishwasher and microwave-safe properties, maintaining this dinnerware set is a breeze. Investing in the Gibson Soho Lounge Round Reactive Glaze Stoneware Dinnerware Set ensures both style and practicality for your dining needs.
Pros:
- Unique artisanal reactive glaze creates vibrant, dreamlike colors and hues.
- Each piece is one-of-a-kind due to the reactive nature of the glaze.
Cons:
- Some users may prefer larger bowl and mug sizes.
5- HomeVss, Pearl Dots Stoneware Dinnerware Set (Purple, 56pc Set)
Elevate your dining experience with the HomeVss Pearl Dots Stoneware Dinnerware Set. This 56-piece set, in a regal purple hue, offers service for 8, making it perfect for family reunions and parties. Crafted with attention to detail, the embossed pearl dots design adds an artisanal touch to your dinner table, making it comfortable and attractive.
Specifications:
| Item | Description |
|---|---|
| Set Includes | – 8 Dinner Plates (10.5″) |
| – 8 Salad Plates (8″) | |
| – 8 Dessert Plates (6″) | |
| – 8 Soup/Pasta Bowls (8″) | |
| – 8 Cereal/Soup Bowls (5.5″) | |
| – 8 Fruit/Dip/Sauce/Ice Cream Bowls (4.5″) | |
| – 8 Mugs (15oz) | |
| Material | High-quality clay material |
| Design | Embossed pearl dots design |
| Durability | Steel embossed mold |
| Special glaze | |
| Fired in long tunnel kiln at 1300°C for 20 hours | |
| Usage | Dishwasher safe |
| Microwave safe | |
| Freezer to oven to table |
Why Should You Buy This?
The HomeVss Pearl Dots Stoneware Dinnerware Set offers both functionality and aesthetics. With a comprehensive 56-piece set, including various plate sizes, bowls, and mugs, it caters to all dining needs for a family or a group of friends. The embossed pearl dots design adds a touch of sophistication to your dining table, making every meal a special occasion.
Crafted from high-quality clay material and fired in a long tunnel kiln, this dinnerware set ensures durability and resilience. Its dishwasher, microwave, and freezer-to-oven-to-table safety features also provide convenience and versatility. Whether cooking a fancy dinner or enjoying a relaxed meal with loved ones, this tableware set will look fantastic.
Pros:
- Extensive 56-piece set, providing service for 8, suitable for family gatherings and parties.
- Beautiful embossed pearl dots design adds elegance and uniqueness to the dinner table.
Cons:
- Some users may find the dinnerware set heavy due to its stoneware construction.
6- Gibson Elite Matisse 16 Piece Double Bowl Dinnerware Set, Cobalt Blue
The 16-piece Gibson Elite Matisse double bowl dinnerware set, With its reactive glazing, darkened rims, and mottled design, Set in Cobalt Blue, oozes elegance. This stunning dinnerware set is sure to elevate the ambiance of any dining room, adding a touch of sophistication to every meal.
Specifications:
| Item | Description |
|---|---|
| Material | Ceramic |
| Set Includes | Four 10.5-inch dinner plates |
| Four 8.5-inch dessert plates | |
| Four 5.25-inch cereal bowls | |
| Four 8.25-inch dinner bowls | |
| Features | Dappled design |
| Reactive glaze | |
| Microwave safe | |
| Dishwasher safe |
Overall, the Gibson Elite Matisse 16 Piece Double Bowl Dinnerware Set in Cobalt Blue is a stylish and practical choice for those looking to enhance their dining experience with a touch of elegance.
Pros:
- Microwave and dishwasher safe for convenient heating and cleaning.
- The Cobalt Blue color adds a vibrant pop to any dining table.
Cons:
- Reactive glaze may lead to variations in appearance between pieces.
Buying Guide: Dinnerware Sets
When shopping for dinnerware sets, you must consider various factors to choose the perfect set for your needs. Follow these steps to make an informed decision:
Assess Your Needs:
Start by assessing how many people you typically serve meals for and whether you need formal or casual dinnerware. Consider your lifestyle and dining habits.
Material Matters:
Dinnerware sets come in various materials such as porcelain, bone china, stoneware, and earthenware. Each material has advantages and disadvantages regarding upkeep, style, and longevity. Select the material that best suits your preferences and lifestyle.
Design and Style:
Choose a look and style that goes well with your current kitchen or dinnerware and your preferences. Whether you prefer classic, modern, or eclectic designs, ensure the dinnerware set enhances the overall aesthetic of your dining space.
Consider the Pieces Included:
Determine the pieces you need in your dinnerware set. Basic sets typically include dinner plates, salad plates, bowls, and mugs, while more comprehensive sets may include additional items like serving platters and bowls. Choose a set that fulfils your specific dining requirements.
Microwave and Dishwasher Safety:
Check whether the dinnerware set is microwave and dishwasher-safe, especially if you prefer the convenience of reheating and cleaning dishes quickly and efficiently.
Evaluate Durability:
Opt for dinnerware that is durable and resistant to chipping, cracking, and scratching, especially if you have young children or tend to use your dishes frequently.
Budget Considerations:
Decide on a budget depending on your needs and choices. Dinnerware sets are available at various price points, so balancing quality with affordability is essential.
Read Reviews:
Read other customers’ reviews before purchasing to learn more about the performance, quality, and longevity of the dinnerware set you’re thinking about. Pay attention to any recurring positive or negative feedback.
Check for Warranty:
Some dinnerware sets have a warranty against defects or damage. Review the warranty terms and conditions to find out what is covered and for how long.
Finalize Your Choice:
After weighing all the options and variables, select the dinnerware set that most closely matches your needs, tastes, and financial situation.
Following these steps, you can confidently select a dinnerware set that enhances your dining experience and adds style to your table for years.
FAQs
What is the best material for dinnerware sets?
The best material for dinnerware sets depends on your preferences and lifestyle. Bone china is prized for its elegance and durability, while stoneware offers a rustic charm and earthy appeal.
Can dinnerware sets go in the microwave?
Many dinnerware sets are microwave-safe, but it’s essential to check the manufacturer’s guidelines to ensure compatibility. Porcelain and stoneware are typically microwave-safe, while delicate materials like bone china may not be suitable for microwave use.
How many pieces should a dinnerware set include?
Dinnerware sets typically include a variety of pieces, such as dinner plates, salad plates, bowls, and mugs or cups. Depending on the manufacturer and style, the number of pieces might vary, but a typical dinnerware set typically has four to six-place settings.
Are expensive dinnerware sets worth it?
Expensive dinnerware sets are often made from high-quality materials and feature intricate designs and craftsmanship, making them worth the investment for special occasions and formal dining. However, there are also affordable options available that offer excellent quality and value.
Conclusion
Choosing the right dinnerware set is essential for enhancing your dining experience and setting the stage for memorable meals with family and friends. Consider factors such as material, style, and durability when selecting a set that reflects your taste and complements your table decor.